Skip to content
All articles
Call Center QA

Call QA Scorecard Template: Free Examples for Support, Sales and HR Calls

Three ready-to-use call QA scorecards (support, sales discovery and HR interviews), written so a person or software can score them the same way. Copy the tables or download the PDF.

Keshav JangidCo-founder, Engineering4 min read

Free download

Get the printable scorecards (PDF).

All three templates on A4, with a scoring guide and a calibration log. We’ll also send the monthly newsletter; leave any time.

A call QA scorecard is the list of checks every call is scored against: what the agent must say or do, how each check is scored and what counts as evidence. A good one gives the same result whether an analyst or software scores the call. This page has three scorecards you can copy and adapt, plus a printable PDF version.

Each template follows the same rules:

  • Mostly yes or no. Binary checks score consistently. Keep judgment calls few and label them.
  • Evidence written down. Every check says what passes, so a score can point to a line in the call.
  • Behavior, not outcome. Score what the agent did. Track outcomes like satisfaction separately.
  • Compliance marked. Checks with legal or contractual weight are labelled, so a single miss is flagged even when the overall score is high.
Preview of the free Proponent call QA scorecard PDF: the inbound support, sales discovery and HR interview scorecards, each check with its type and what passes.

Template 1: inbound support call

#CheckTypePasses when
1Greeting with company and own nameYes/noBoth stated in the first 15 seconds
2Identity verified before account detailsComplianceTwo verification items confirmed before account data is shared
3Issue restated to the callerYes/noAgent summarizes the problem in their own words
4Correct process followedYes/noSteps match the knowledge-base article for the issue type
5Hold over 60 seconds explainedYes/noReason given and caller checked on before 60 seconds
6Required disclosure readComplianceText read in full, not paraphrased
7Resolution or next step confirmedYes/noAgent states what happens next and by when
8Callback offered when unresolvedYes/noOffered whenever the issue is not closed on the call
9Further help offered before closingYes/noAgent asks if anything else is needed
10Distress or escalation handled wellJudgmentFlagged for analyst review when the caller asks for a manager or shows distress

Template 2: sales discovery call

#CheckTypePasses when
1Agenda set and agreedYes/noRep states the purpose and checks it with the buyer in the first 3 minutes
2Current process exploredYes/noRep asks how the buyer handles the problem today
3Pain quantifiedYes/noBuyer states a cost, time or volume figure
4Decision process askedYes/noRep asks who else is involved and how a decision gets made
5Timeline askedYes/noRep asks when a solution needs to be in place and why
6Competition or alternatives askedYes/noRep asks what else is being considered, including doing nothing
7Talk-listen balanceYes/noBuyer speaks for at least 40% of the call
8Next step bookedYes/noA dated next meeting or action is agreed before the call ends
9No unapproved pricing or discount promisesComplianceNo price, discount or contract term outside the approved range

Template 3: HR interview call (exit, engagement or new-hire check-in)

#CheckTypePasses when
1Purpose and confidentiality explainedComplianceInterviewer states why the call is happening and how answers are used
2Consent to continue and recordComplianceExplicit yes before the first question
3All guide questions coveredYes/noEvery mandatory question in the guide is asked
4Vague answers followed upYes/noAt least one follow-up on any answer under one sentence
5No leading questionsYes/noQuestions do not suggest an answer
6Escalation topics flaggedComplianceHarassment, safety, legal or distress topics trigger the escalation step
7Employee's own words capturedYes/noSummary includes verbatim quotes for the main reasons given
8Close and next steps explainedYes/noInterviewer thanks the employee and says what happens with the feedback

How to weight and score

Keep scoring simple so people trust it:

  • Each yes/no check is worth one point. The call score is points earned divided by checks that applied.
  • A compliance check that fails flags the call regardless of the score.
  • Judgment checks do not count toward the score. They route the call to an analyst.
  • Mark checks "not applicable" when they could not apply (no hold, so no hold check), instead of passing them.
Proponent QA view with sample data: a support call scored 83 out of 100 against the inbound support scorecard, with the failed refund-policy check linked to the line at 4:12 in the transcript.

Calibrate before you trust the numbers

Score the same 30 calls with two analysts, then compare. Where the two disagree, the wording of the check is ambiguous. Rewrite it and score again. If you use software to score calls, run the same 30 calls through it and compare in the same way. Repeat monthly.

Score every call, not a sample

These templates work for manual QA. They work better when every call is scored, because a 3% sample rarely catches the compliance misses that matter most. Proponent checks every call against your own scorecard and writes the results into the platform you already use. Read the full guide to call center QA on every call, see how voice operations teams use Proponent, or book a demo.

Frequently asked questions

What should a call QA scorecard include?

A call QA scorecard should list the specific behaviors an agent must show on a call, how each is scored (usually yes or no), what evidence counts as a pass, and which checks are compliance-critical. Eight to fifteen checks is a practical size.

How many items should a QA scorecard have?

Eight to fifteen checks is enough to cover process, compliance and customer experience without making scoring slow or inconsistent. Fewer, sharper checks score more reliably than long lists.

Should a QA scorecard use weights?

Simple scoring with compliance checks as automatic flags is usually clearer than weighted points. If you do weight, keep weights few and document why, so agents understand their score.

Can the same scorecard be used for manual and automated QA?

Yes, if each check is written with clear evidence of what passes. Precise yes-or-no checks score the same way for a person and for software, which is what makes calibration possible.

Free download

Get the printable scorecards (PDF).

All three templates on A4, with a scoring guide and a calibration log. We’ll also send the monthly newsletter; leave any time.

Understand every call. Hand off the routine ones.

Book a demo. Bring a call type and the SOP you run it by, and we’ll walk through how Proponent would handle it.